Reviews
HTC Desire Review (U.S. Cellular Edition): Classic phone, new country
August 26, 2010 | by Andrew Kameka
Android Phones and Devices, Carriers, HTC
In an era where consumers want mega-screens, dual-core processors, the latest version of Android, and features as gaudy as kickstands and HDMI connectivity, is there any place for devices that are just at the edge of “super phone”? Will people still have room in their hearts and pockets for a phone that was released several months ago, which translates to years in Android’s rapidly expanding legacy?
The short answer is yes.
The HTC Desire has finally jumped from the UK to the United States through a deal with regional carrier U.S. Cellular. Commonly referred to as “the Nexus One running Sense,” the Desire doesn’t have the phone-on-steroids specs that have made the HTC EVO and Motorola Droid X two of the hottest phones on the market. However, the Desire does have the core features that make it able to rest proudly with those phones: an eye-catching 3.7-inch screen, zippy 1 GHz Snapdragon processor, and 512 MB of RAM to handle all of the apps that your heart de…no, I will not make that pun. Let’s take a look at the device.
HARDWARE
The Temptations famously sang that beauty is only skin deep, but boy does this phone have beautiful skin. The Desire has a smooth finish that feels incredibly comforting and more durable than the hard plastic you may have seen on some devices. And while other popular phones have the feedback buttons on the glass part of the screen, the Desire has a more than capable optical trackpad and physical buttons that decrease the likelihood of accidental pressing. This setup isn’t perfect since the back and search functions share one button accessible by tapping the left or right side. Maybe this was intended to be an innovative space saver, but it’s initially irksome.
The phone is an otherwise physically pleasing specimen. I’ve held 30-40 Android devices over the past two years, and the Desire ranks among my favorites to touch. While the Hero may be too feeble for some and the EVO obscenely large to others, the Desire rests in the middle ground that’s just right. Goldilocks would be happy with this phone that has a warm TFT LCD screen ideal for gaming, watching videos, and browsing the web. Those activities are also aided by the 1 GHz processor that is becoming ubiquitous among Android devices.
Call quality is excellent on the Desire as both the microphone and receiver operated well during testing. However, the speaker doesn’t perform as well during music playback or in speaker mode. The sound quality tends to be downgraded and muffled when set to its maximum level, so I’d advise keeping it one or two clicks below max capacity. That will provide better sound quality and still make music or your contact’s voice audible.
CAMERA/CAMCORDER
Less is more in many places, including pixels. Despite having only 5 megapixels to snap photos to that of the 8 megapixel-sporting phones like the EVO 4G, the Desire takes decent photos and videos. On a sunny Florida afternoon, photos came out in great shape and top-notch detail. In dimly lit night clubs, things were less fruitful, even with LED flash; however, the resulting photos were still passable.
The camera software allows for adjusting brightness or contrast, and there’s also an LED flash to help capture images just the way you want. As for video, users can shoot up to 720p video that doesn’t suffer compression woes as bad as the EVO initially offered, but still offers quality video. Here’s a look.
SOFTWARE
HTC has done well for itself with the customized version of Android known as Sense. It enhances the overall experience of the device with major visual tweaks, custom widgets, and a more graphic-intensive interface. But those virtues are trailed by several faults, chief among them being the out-dated software launching on the Desire. Yes Android 2.1 will still provide a great experience, but it’s disappointing that the Desire doesn’t yet have the many new features and improvements added to the Android 2.2 version of Sense. We’ve covered Sense many times, but take our word for it; it’s great.
The Desire comes with a mature interface and eye-catching live wallpapers that enhance the experience. It also offers several applications pre-loaded by U.S. Cellular and partners.
- City ID can lookup number locations or show the city of incoming calls. This is a free trial of the monthly subscription service that costs $1.99. It is rather unnecessary unless you frequently get calls from random people you’ve never heard.
- My Contacts Backup is an alternative to Google Contacts sync. U.S. Cellular offers a backup at uscellular.com/mycontactsbackup so you have an extra place to store phone numbers.
- MySpace is pre-loaded. Yeah, that MySpace.
- QuickOffice reads Microsoft Office documents on the go. People who need to read and edit documents can upgrade to the pro version.
- ToneRoom Deluxe - A launcher shortcut to a mobile website for purchasing ringtones and Callback tones.
- Your Navigator is the carrier branded version of TeleNav (similar to ATT or Sprint Navigator)
VERDICT
The Desire is a redux of a device which you are familiar. It is physically similar to the Nexus One but internally more akin to the range of HTC-produced phones that you’ve probably lusted for when seeing friends sport their EVO’s or Incredible’s in your presence. Finally available in the United States, the Desire remains a very viable option for American consumers.
Until the Samsung Galaxy S comes out, the Desire is unquestionably the best phone available on U.S. Cellular. People who have opted for U.S. Cellular may find it difficult to grab a non-roaming signal when traveling outside of the confines of the regional carrier’s coverage zones, but they will rarely find it difficult to enjoy using an HTC Desire. The combination of quality hardware and enjoyable software makes this a desir….nope, won’t make that pun either.














ok!
The Desire didn’t jump over from the UK, it came from all over Europe
*proud to be a Dutch user of the Desire. Great device!
'Until the Samsung Epic 4G comes out, the Desire is unquestionably the best phone available on U.S. Cellular.' Andrew, are you hinting that US Cellular will be getting the Epic 4G version of the SGS? I've been patiently waiting to hear which version they'll be offering…
He didnt say Epic 4g, he just said Galaxy S.
U.S. Cellular is slated to get the Galaxy S; I'm not sure if it was specifically the Epic, however. I've edited the article until I can locate confirmation which model they are getting.
The epic is for Sprint
The Desire is an awesome device and it's hard to choose wether is Desire or Galaxy S the king.
I used a Desire for 3 months, until it was stolen. Now I have a Galaxy S, I love both phones equally.
The Galaxy has a better display and camera, the Desire has better UI and it looks way better than the Galaxy. I hate this "Nth chinese iPhone-clone" look, but the super amoled is awesome.
My recent post Mától így zenélsz
I'm a Desire user from Austria and I am getting quite confused about some things in your article.
First of all, you are writing about a "warm LCD TFT" display.. I heard some news about HTC having a shortage on the OLED displays originally shipped with the desire. So is the U.S. version entirely made with TFT displays? Did you have a look at the European OLED Desire and can you compare the two display technologies, e.g. "which Desire looks better"? I for myself am enjoying the OLED display on the Desire very much, very clear and sharp colors. (compared to the iPhone 3GS which is running an LCD display for example)
Second, you are writing that Desire is getting shipped with Android 2.1 in the U.S. Here in Europe the update to 2.2 got released on August 1th (on unbranded phones), and the updates for branded phones are being released right now, some carriers being earlier than others.
Greetings from Europe,
Tobias
Tobias, the Desire for U.S. Cellular uses LCD. I don't have the original European version so I can't compare the two.
Also, it ships with 2.1 and hasn't had 2.2 delivered to the phone yet.
Hey Andrew, thanks for your quick reply.
So that's interesting news for me. Hearing that Europe's beloved high-end Android smartphone hits the U.S. market with a delay of 6 months and then with an (at least technically) inferior display and no 2.2 Update (which – as I wrote earlier – is live in Europe since August 1st). I wonder what HTC is having in mind, because the U.S. market already has got newer/better Android devices at about the same pricing (Evo 4G, DroidX, Nexus One ..) than a slimmed-down Desire.
Tobias
I got my first smarthone last year from here. I was very very lucky
http://gadgetsales.net/exclusive You can get GalaxyS, iPhone and other goodies if you’re eligible. They are doing this promotion for some time this spring.